The 8 Best Pizza Restaurants in South Boston (2023 Guide)
Just because New York is the gold standard of American pizza, don’t overlook Boston’s bevy of brilliant pizzerias churning out delightfully cheesy pies.
Buried amongst the countless cheap and nasty pizza places is a selection of cheesy artisans bringing us some of the best Italian cuisines this country has to offer right at our doorstep!
So if you’re sick of your usual late-night pie and want to experience a genuine slice of Italy, we’ve put together a list of the best dough wrangling restaurants in South Boston on offer.
See also our articles on the best pizza restaurants in Boston Back Bay and restaurants in Boston South End
Address: 205 L St, Boston, MA 02127
Phone: (617) 268-5800
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway / Delivery
Sal’s Ristorante & Pizza first opened its doors in the heart of South Boston over thirty years ago in 1986. Since then, it has become a local institution, known for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere.
This restaurant in South Boston is family-owned and operated, and pride themselves on using only the freshest ingredients in their dishes. Sal’s are also well know for their delicious Sub sandwiches and can be found corner of L and 8th for a touch of Sicily in Southie!
Address: 260 W Broadway, Boston, MA 02127
Phone: (617) 268-9600
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway / Delivery
If you’re in the mood for some truly delicious Italian food, there’s only one place to go – Pizzeria 260. This family-run restaurant has been a favorite in the South Boston area for years, and it’s easy to see why.
Their menu is packed with all sorts of mouth-watering specialties, from pizza and pasta to chicken and veal dishes. And whether you’re looking to dine in, take out, or have your meal delivered, they’re more than happy to accommodate. Plus, their staff is always friendly and attentive, making sure you have a dining experience that’s second to none.
Address: 10 Old Colony Ave, Boston, MA 02127
Phone: (781) 951-2029
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway
Bardo’s Bar Pizza is one of the leading restaurants in South Boston, located at Castle Island Brewery. Bardo’s specializes in South Shore Bar Style Pizzas, a cult favorite! The menu includes pizza, sandwiches, salads and more, while incorporating Castle Island Beer into the recipes.
The restaurant was awarded Boston magazine best of Boston bar pie 2022. Visit Bardo’s for a delicious meal and experience the best of what Boston has to offer!
Address: 425 W Broadway, Boston, MA 02127
Phone: 617 765 8636
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway
This contemporary American tavern is situated on South Boston’s bustling West Broadway and offers a selection of rustic, wood-grilled dishes, comfort food favorites, and wood-fired pizzas.
The yuppie community that resides in Southie frequents the well-stocked bar. The quaint room, formerly the only department store in the neighborhood, has tile floors and original tin ceilings.
Stop by for a pie (the Burrata Pizza is usually a good option here) while you watch the big game, drink some beer with the boys, and then return the next day for its bacon- and egg-laden Breakfast Pizza to start your hangover recovery over brunch.
Address: 672 East Broadway South Boston, MA 02127
Phone: 617 269 7680
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway / Delivery
Nestled within East Broadway, you will find Cafe Porto Bello. This charming establishment only accepts cash and serves all the food that proprietors Vincent Amato and Steve Costa grew up with in the Italian countryside.
They’ve chosen to make the room uncomplicated to create a more welcoming, family-friendly environment for both regulars and strangers alike to experience Italian cuisine.
One look at Cafe Porto Bello’s appetizer menu might make you rethink sticking to your favorite standard pie as you glance over signature dishes like The Scallops Rockefeller, served in a shell. The pizza, though, is guaranteed to wow as no matter what toppings you choose, they come atop what can only be described as Boston’s finest melted mozzarella.
Address: 108 L Street, South Boston, MA
Phone: 617 268 2733
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway / Delivery
Since the L Street Diner & Pizzeria in South Boston first opened its doors in 1986, they have taken pride in creating a restaurant with something to offer everyone.
They’ve been able to meld a modern setting with old-world Italy by fusing a distinctive menu and wide variety of fresh ingredients with a sexy, modern décor. When the store was opened on the corner of L Street and E Broadway they soon gained a devoted following from people from all walks of life.
Their quality is unsurpassed today as they continue to expand into the greater Boston area. They are dedicated to maintaining the original level of high-quality food, reliable service, and a comfortable family atmosphere.
Address: 443 W Broadway, Boston, MA 02127
Phone: 617 993 8080
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway / Delivery
Are you looking for a cozy, welcoming, family-friendly restaurant? Look no further than Capo in South Boston. They offer various inventive and expertly prepared pizzas for supper and a wide range of drinks designed to satisfy any palate. There is no need to limit yourself, though, as you can experience all Italian cuisine with several food and beverage alternatives.
The mouthwatering pizzas and freshly home-cooked pasta are simply some of the best in their class and distinguish Capo above its Boston competitors. Afterward, you must taste their authentic Italian desserts, such as gelato and affogato, to cap off dinner with the ideal balance of flavors. Your night isn’t quite over yet, however, as you can travel downstairs to The Supper Club, a terrific combination of a bar, lounge, and live music.
You might even run into the city’s favorite reggae band! In addition, the bar offers a wide variety of creative beverages, including a must-try Old Fashioned on draught.
Address: 416 West Broadway Boston, MA, 02127
Phone: (857) 496-1906
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway / Delivery
Otto has been working to improve the pizza experience since opening its first slice store in 2009. The high-quality, local ingredients are the foundation, followed by inventive toppings. Mashed Potatoes? Tortellini? Cranberries on a pizza? One of their most well-liked pies is “The Masher,” which has mashed potatoes, scallions, and bacon. Sounds strange? Trust me when I say this unlikely combination is worth every cent.
Otto makes every pizza flawless and every slice unforgettable, never failing to improve and innovate upon their previous whacky combinations.
Complete with top-notch service for their dine-in and takeaway service, Otto is a pizza lovers’ new favorite Friday night destination.
Address: 345 congress street, Fort Point / Boston, ma 02210
Phone: (617) 345 0005
Services: Dine-in / Takeaway / Delivery
The inside of this Fort Point restaurant has an urban-farmhouse feel, making it the perfect setting for the variety of wood-fired pizzas topped with a variety of fresh vegetables and homemade toppings (e.g., duck sausage, mozzarella, smoked pancetta).
In addition, all of Pastoral’s pies can be created with what is possibly the most fabulous gluten-free crust in the entire city, so celiacs and those who can’t handle wheat can feel at ease here.
Wrap Up
South Boston pizza lovers can rest easy knowing they don’t have to travel far to experience some of the country’s best pies. Nestled among the numerous cash-grab pizza shops are some dedicated and passionate chefs providing artfully made cheesy creations and an authentic Italian atmosphere.
So the only thing left to do is grab a partner and taste a slice of Italy for yourself.
