Pizza Dimension

Best Pizza Restaurants in New Braunfels Texas

Whether you are visiting Braunfels or have been a resident for a while, you may be wondering where the best place is to get pizza. Look no further, because we have compiled a list of the best pizza places in town! From traditional Italian-style pizzas to unique combos, these pizza restaurants in New Braunfels Texas will satisfy any craving.

restaurants in new braunfels texas

List of Restaurants in Article

Address: 311 FM306, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 310 0551
Services: Dine In / Takeout / Delivery

In 2021, Chef Jimmy and Annette White opened Above Ground Pizza after the unexpected closure of the best joint in New Braunfels in 2018, the Underground Pizza.

Above Ground Pizza features a wood-burning oven and pizza dough with a sourdough starter. Fresh salads, grinder sandwiches and calzones are featured on the menu, and the pizzas incorporate traditional and unique flavors.

The concept of AGP was designed to be chef-driven. Fires to be attended to, sausages to smoke, starters, and sourdough to maintain. They purposely stepped back in time and did things the old-school way. Every speck of food produced here is made with love and the intent for you to feel that love.

Opens Mon. to Sat. 11am – 8pm.

Address: 197 S Seguin Ave, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 327 1199
Services: Dine In / Takeout 

Dave and Christina Cinotto bought The Oyster Bar with a business partner in 2013. And since then, the full-service kitchen and seafood bar has become a staple of the food and drink scene in Downtown New Braunfels.

With a nod to the historical past of the building, previously occupied by Ludwig’s Leather for more than 50 years, Bootleggers Pizza Parlor is a prohibition-era juke joint that specializes in delicious pizza by the slice, 22 drafts, unique cocktails, beer billiards, games, and more.

It’s a pub-ish atmosphere that is appropriate to take kids around dinner that turns more bar-ish at night. There’s a bar with seats, T.V.s, and a mini Dave and Busters setup at the back, with pool tables, arcade games, Pacman, and a basketball game.

The pizza comes in two sizes, 15″ and 12″. Their pizza is also available by the slice, and the kitchen stays open late. So at least stop in for a slice if you are in a rush. Pasta, sandwiches, sides and N.Y. Cheesecake for dessert are also a must-try.

Opens Sun. to Thurs. 11:30am – 9:30pm Weekends 11:30am – 10:30am. Happy Hour Mon. to Fri. 3-6pm.

Address: 2345 TX-337 Loop, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 626 9782
Services: Dine In / Takeout 

Since 2009, New York Pizza Pub has been serving pizza in the New Braunfels area. As the name suggests, they serve traditional New York Style thin crust pizza alongside other Italian favorites, wings, and more.

Voted as “Best Pizza” in New Braunfels 8 years in a row.

Homemade Italian favorites on the menu include family size bake ziti, lasagna alongside meatball subs and calzones. Pizzas are design your own style, with a gluten free crust and whole wheat crust options. The toppings are pepperoni, Sausage, mushrooms, onions, black olives, jalapeños, pineapple and more.

Or go for the house speciality pies like the Cooper with white wine garlic sauce with artichokes and sun-dried tomatoes, the Bacon Cheeseburger, Garlic Veggie, Six cheese pizza, Gnarly Surfer Dude with pineapple, ham and bacon or the Butcher Shop with pepperoni, Sausage, ham, and bacon.

Open daily Mon. & Tues. 3-8pm, Wed. to Sat. 11am – 9pm, Sun. 11am – 8pm.

Address: 2180 TX-46 Ste 107, New Braunfels, TX 78132
Phone: (830) 214 0652
Services: Dine In / Curbside Pickup / Catering

Mattenga’s Pizzeria is the real love child of husband and wife duo Matthew and Hengam Stanfield. Feeling inspired by their love of hosting dinner parties and making fresh pizza, they decided to go into the pizzeria business in their hometown of San Antonio, Texas.

Because of their love for hosting dinner parties and making fresh pasta, making pizza for people from scratch, they sold their house in New Mexico and bought a failing Pizzeria in 2014. So it’s been eight years in this business. Last 2018 they opened their second location in San Antonio.

Opens Mon. to Thur. 11am – 9pm, Fri. & Sat – 11am – 10pm and Sun. 11am – 9pm.

Address: 194 W San Antonio St, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 609 9782
Services: Dine In / Curbside Pickup / Delivery

When Calahan’s opened in 1997, there were no other bars downtown. Since then, Downtown New Braunfels has experienced a rebirth, with Calahan’s playing a significant role. Downtown has become a vibrant and viable destination for food & drink, and pizza is no exception.

Owners Jay Beringer and Philip Nauert have deep family roots in New Braunfels. They’ve been in the pizza business since 2008 and love the limitless number of creative combinations. They say it all starts with the dough, and Calahan takes the time to make it fresh daily.

Calahan’s Pub is the place to go if you’re looking for pizza & beer downtown or a late-night option for some quality pie.

Address: 1198 Gruene Rd, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 629 2077
Services: Dine In / Curbside Pickup / Delivery

Voted Best in New Braunfels, 2018, Infernos Wood Fired Oven & Spirits has been a Gruene, Texas, local favorite since 2013. Owner Cary Hamer attributes the restaurants 5 1/2 years of success to his ingredients and staff. Known for its wood-fired oven, hot artisan-style pizzas, flavorful sandwiches, signature drinks, fresh salads, and unique appetizers.

If you’re up for a challenge, try their very own Trinidad Scorpion Pepper features Scorpion Pepper sausage, along with tomatoes, basil and shaved parmesan cheese. It’s a spicy dish, but the heat doesn’t overwhelm the other flavors. The second most popular pizza at Infernos is the bacon chicken ranch, a tasty pizza topped with signature pizza sauce, chicken, bacon, roma tomatoes, basil and a drizzling of ranch dressing.

Besides pizza, the menu offers irresistible appetizers, salads large enough to be meals themselves and sandwiches you’re not likely to find anywhere else.

Opens Sun. to Thur. 11am- 9pm and Weekends 11am – 10pm.

Address: 263 TX-337 Loop, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 620 6900
Services: Dine In / Takeout / Delivery

Boss pizza dough is made from scratch throughout the day with their secret recipe. The cheese is 100% mozzarella graded in-house with high-quality toppings. These contributing factors genuinely make it the best darn pizza in Texas.

Through the years, Boss has added more mouth-watering choices. Wings so good that you’ll swear you’re dreaming. Also, the best burgers are made with high-quality beef and cooked on a flat-top grill the way a burger is supposed to be cooked.

As a company racked up numerous awards. They take their food seriously, and every item is always made to order.

Opens daily, Sun. to Thur. 11am – 9pm and Weekends 11am – 10pm.

Address: 272 FM306 Suite 106, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 609 9040
Services: Dine In / Take out / Curbside pickup

MOD Pizza is a purpose-led, people-first brand founded in Seattle in 2008 by serial entrepreneurs Scott and Ally Svenson.

One of the most exciting parts of the business is the name itself. The term “MOD” stands for Made On Demand. So every individual can personalize their pizza exactly how they want it.

As the pioneer of the fast-casual pizza category, MOD introduced speed, individual style, and compelling value to the pizza world.

The Company serves individual artisan-style pizzas and salads made on demand, allowing customers to create their pizzas and salads with any combination of over 40 toppings and sauces, all for one incredible price.

Their organization and culture are also unique and aim to wow customers with the best pizza dining experience they have ever had.

Today, MOD is the largest fast-casual pizza concept and one of North America’s fastest-growing restaurant brands. With over 548 stores across 29 states, MOD is committed to creating a cool place to eat and an inspiring place to work by providing community and opportunity to over 10,000 Squad members.

See MOD Pizza sizes and Crusts Type

Address: 1850 W, 1850 TX-46 Ste 101, New Braunfels, TX 78132
Phone: (830) 302 7204
Services: Dine In / Take out / Delivery

Owned by a former arcade owner Jason Stout, who describes himself as eccentric and passionate about pizza. He’s been selling pizza for 15 years. Stout added a food truck in 2012.

Stout says regardless of which location guests visit, they’ll find dishes that rely on handmade dough and are produced without preservatives.

Stout’s makes their dough fresh every day and never frozen. As a result, you can enjoy their wide range of flavorful pizzas with 100% real mozzarella and freshly kneaded dough. Stout says he loves when people express how much they like the pizza.

You can find specialty pizzas, along with their signature pizzas, calzones, pasta, and salads you have come to love.

Stout’s casual environment ensures you feel at home as you indulge in restaurant-style delicacies. In addition, their locally crafted beer is an ideal addition you didn’t know you needed.

Stout’s has two pizzerias in San Antonio, one in New Braunfels and a trattoria at a vineyard in Fredericksburg. The store opens Mon. to Thur. 4-9pm & Weekends 11am – 9pm.

Address: 211 W Lincoln St, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Phone: (830) 608 0999
Services: Curbside pickup / Take out / Delivery

pizza restaurants in new braunfels texas

Di’s Homemade pizza is a family-run business right across the street from Schlitterbahn’s Blastenhoff. Every pizza is made with fresh homemade dough, hand-tossed, rolled, topped with fresh meats and vegetables with a generous helping of Di’s special selected mozzarella cheese and then cooked on stones inside good old Bertha, the pizza oven.

You won’t find waiters or waitresses here, and there are very few tables and chairs in the pizza restaurant, so most people tend to drop by and get the pizza to go. All pizzas are large, so you can share or keep them as leftovers for the next day.

Opens Wed. and Thurs. 3-9pm and Fri. to Sun. 11am – 9pm. Mon. and Tues. CLOSED.

Wrapping Up

The great thing about Braunfels, Texas, is that there is plenty of fantastic pizza restaurants to visit. So whether you’re looking for a quick slice on the go or a romantic dinner for two, a pizza joint in Braunfels will fit the bill. Whether a local or a visitor, you’ll find the perfect pizza spot in Braunfels.

Recent Posts

what is gluten free pizza

What is gluten free pizza?

What is Gluten Free pizza? Gluten free pizza is becoming increasingly more common and popular for people with gluten intolerance or celiac disease. But what