Pizza Dimension

Top Pizza Restaurants in Woodstock New York for 2023

If you’re looking for the best pizza restaurants in Woodstock New York, you’ve come to the right place. We’ve gathered a list of some of our favorite spots, so you can find the perfect place to indulge in some delicious pizza. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pie or something a bit more adventurous, we’ve got you covered.

restaurants in woodstock new york

Address: 138 Tinker St, Woodstock, NY 12498
Phone: (845) 679 2700
Services: Dine In / Takeout 

Woodstock Pizza Theater is an upscale, hip, and inviting restaurant ​featuring authentic, Neapolitan-style, brick-oven pizza and a full menu of Italian dishes in Woodstock, NY. Along with what many proclaim is the best pizza they have ever experienced, people love their warm and inviting ambience/vibe, music, and professional and courteous staff.

Woodstock Pizza Theatre also prides itself on having a menu dedicated to the Vegan community. They enjoy catering to the vegan/vegetarian community.

The menu at Woodstock Pizza Theater is extensive. There are many items to choose from on the menu, and everything is made from scratch. In addition, the restaurant has a full bar, including a substantial selection of organic wines.

Address: 51 Mill Hill Rd, Woodstock, NY 12498
Phone: (845) 679 7969
Services: Dine In / Takeout / Delivery

Catskill Mountain Pizza has been a locally owned and operated family business since 1998. All of the items on our menu are made fresh daily.

Chill out on the garden patio of this beatnik brick joint with their famous 12-inch slice of New York-style pie and one of the 40-plus craft, domestic, and imported beers. There’s live music on the weekends and the occasional “tap takeover” for when you want to pair a local brew with a big ol’ slice of pizza.

In attempts to cater to all sorts of diets, CMP has gluten-free options, spelt crust, and soy cheese. Plus, you know, regular New York-style pizza. The combinations are endless when considering the various crusts, sizes, and toppings. This is the place to call when you’re seriously hungry — the a la carte slices are a whopping 12 inches and you can order an extra-large pizza that measures 24 inches in diameter.

Address: 22 Mill Hill Rd, Woodstock, NY 12498
Phone: (845) 679 2108
Services: Dine In / Takeout / Delivery

The sign out front says it all “Made By Hand Each and Every Day!” Among their certified organic breads are San Francisco sourdough, Nine Mixed Rye, Peasant Bread, Olive Bread, Whole Wheat Catskill, and the very popular Oat and Cranberry Porridge Bread — plus many more.

The bakery also is famous for a wide selection of American and French pastries including a Pecan Sticky Bun, Cheese Streusel Danish, a lemon and currant scone, triple chocolate cookies and more. They also serve a regular cafe menu of breakfast sandwiches, cereals, homemade soups and specials of the day.

To continue to serve the many local customers who have been coming to the location for decades, the company opened a temporary kiosk onsite that offers a limited menu and one very special addition — sourdough crust woodfired pizza on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays.

Address: 43 Mill Hill Rd, Woodstock, NY 12498
Services: Dine In / Takeout / Delivery

The Mud Club is a wood-fired bakery, cafe and sourdough pizza restaurant all rolled up into one. Everything is made fresh daily, and their fairytale-like surroundings make it feel like you’re dining in a secret garden.

Come to this cafe to dine at if you feel hungry after gazing at Woodstock Artists Association & Museum. Tasty breakfast bagels, bagel sandwiches and egg sandwiches can make a good impression on you. Many visitors come to try good almond croissants, Brezeln and chocolate cookies. The Mud Club has delicious wine among its drinks. Get your meal started with great iced coffee, tea or latte.

The intimate atmosphere of this place allows customers to relax after a hard-working day. The excellent staff welcomes people all year round. Prices at this spot claim to be average. The cute decor can amaze you.

Wrap Up

In conclusion, Woodstock, New York offers a diverse range of pizza restaurants that cater to various tastes and preferences. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or a sit-down meal, Woodstock has some of the best pizza restaurants in the area.

Related Articles