Pizza Dimension

Best Pizza Restaurant in Springfield Ohio - 2023 Guide

Looking for the best pizza restaurant in Springfield Ohio? You’re in luck! We’ve compile a list of the nine best pizza places in town. From classic pizzerias to unique spots, there’s something for everyone on this list. So, what are you waiting for? Grab your friends and check out some of these amazing restaurants!

restaurant in springfield ohio

Top 9 Pizza Restaurants List

Address: 433 Dayton Ave, Springfield, OH 45506
Phone: (937) 322 3791
Services: Curbside pickup / Delivery / Catering

Catanzaro’s Pizza & Subs is a fresh produce store that sells old world style pizza and subs with a long history of serving Springfield residents some of the best Italian food in the region.

Catanzaro’s signature pizza crust, sauce, Italian bread, lasagna, chicken wings, and salads are additive and preservative-free and made fresh daily onsite.

pizza restaurant in springfield ohio

Catanzaro’s also sells the highest quality seasonal fancy fruits, fresh vegetables, bulk novelty candies, 30 varieties of potato chips, freshly packaged desserts, and showcased ice cream treats, amongst many other items. 

They offer 3 sizes of pizza, a 12″, 14″ and 16″ with the BLT their specialty pizza. Gluten free pizza and take and bake options are also available.

Catanzaro’s are open Monday to Thursday and Sat. 11am – 8:15pm, Friday 2 – 8:15pm, Sun. CLOSED.

Address: 411 Upper Valley Pike #4003, Springfield, OH 45504
Phone: (937) 324 1751
Services: Dine-in / Drive-through / Delivery

The Buckeye Barn is a combination deli, convenience store, and pizza restaurant in Springfield Ohio owned by U.S. Army trained Chef Phil Morrow.

buckeye barn restaurant in Springfield Ohio

They offer specialty and gluten-free pizzas, fried chicken, burgers, wings, and sandwiches. They appreciate reservations for special events and parties of 12 or more guests. The restaurant has a fifty-seat dining hall with four large-screen televisions, and their business hours are Sunday-Thursday, 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. and Friday & Saturday, 10 a.m. to 11 p.m.

Address: 652 N Limestone St, Springfield, OH 45503
Phone: (937) 324 1751
Services: Dine-in / Drive-through / Delivery 

The Hickory Inn has been a pillar of Springfield for more than 70 years, known for its distinctive log cabin style and delicious food. Today, it continues to serve an upscale but comforting menu that is ideal for meals from a family dinner to a romantic date or watching a sports game with friends.

hickory inn pizza in springfiled ohio

In keeping with the family “theme”, the menu offers children’s selections, as well as sandwiches, soups and a variety of dinners and pizzas. At the cozy bar, patrons can enjoy a meal and watch a sporting event on the flat-screen TV. 

Reservations for lunch and dinner are not accepted, but its definitely worth the wait.

From Tuesday to Friday, they are open for lunch from 11:00 am to 1:30 pm, and for dinner from Monday to Thursday, they are open from 5:00 pm to 9:30 pm, and 10.30 pm Fridays and Saturdays.

Address: 1718 N Limestone St, Springfield, OH 45503
Phone: (888) 294 5464
Services: Dine-in / Take out / Delivery 

Cassano’s has multiple locations around Ohio that provide customers with an array of pizza and subs. Try their veggie, ham & cheese, BBQ subs, or the Cassani, Cassano’s original Mediterranean flatbread piled high with toppings.

Their veggie, Hog Wild, and Big Cheese pizzas are expertly made with quality ingredients, in addition to their more affordable but equally delicious single-topping pizzas.

Cassano's Pizza King Springfield Ohio

If that wasn’t enough pizza for you, Cassano’s also offers a 30-inch Party Pizza available for delivery to your next big birthday party at home. The Party Pizza is perfect for large groups and can feed up to 20 people.

With a long history of serving pizza, Today’s Casanno is the pizza king of Ohio with a diverse menu to appease any appetite.

Address: 406 W Harding Rd, Springfield, OH 45504
Phone: (937) 398 1700
Services: Dine-in / Take out / Delivery 

Mikey’s famous pizza is a thin-crust, St.Louis-style pie– cooked to perfection and served with various toppings – Mikey encourages his customers to build their own pies from his extensive list of toppings.

And as a traditional family-style, small-business pizzeria, Mikey’s Pizza Restaurant in Springfield Ohio has some tried and true traditional takes on calzones, wings, salads, and cheesy bread. Mikey’s also offers rooms to host events and parties and delivery options using the DoorDash app service.

Address: 1200 N Bechtle Ave, Springfield, OH 45504
Phone: (937) 505 3478
Services: Dine-in / Curbside pickup / Delivery 

Rapid Fired Pizza in Springfield is a cafeteria-style, fast-casual pizza restaurant with 28 locations in the United States. Co-founded by a group of experienced entrepreneurs, it offers build-your-own pizzas, customized pizzas, salads, breadsticks, and desserts cooked in 180 seconds in custom-built conveyor-belt ovens.

Rapid Fire Pizza in Springfield

The menu includes thin-crust or pan pizzas, calzones, and sweet dessert pies. The dining area is family-friendly with six mounted televisions, and beverages include Pepsi products, craft beers, and wines. The restaurant recently added vegan cheese to its menu and is open on weekdays from 11AM to 9PM and on weekends from 11AM to 10PM.

Address: 325 N Fountain Ave, Springfield, OH 45504
Phone: (937) 324 33 54
Services: Dine-in / Take out / Delivery 

Station 1 Bar is a restaurant and bar located in Springfield, Ohio. It was built in the 1950s and has had several owners over the years, including Diane’s Pizza Place, Cory’s Pizza Place, and Dan Hearlihy. The current owners, Sara and David Montei and Julie and Doug Addis, bought it in August 2013.

Station 1 Restaurant in Springfield Ohio

The menu at Station 1 includes pizza, subs, sandwiches, wraps, chicken wings, salads and appetizers, with 52 selections of beer on tap, many from local breweries. Station 1 also offers indoor seating, with a patio out back with views of Buck Creek. Special events at Station 1 include trivia nights on Wednesdays, open mic nights on Thursdays, and live music on the patio on Friday and Saturday nights.

Address: 1411 Moorefield Rd, Springfield, OH 45503
Phone: (937) 399 7265
Services: Dine-in / Curbside pickup 

Short Stop Pizza is a full-service restaurant and market in Springfield that has been serving delicious food since 2000. They offer a wide variety of menu items including pizza, chicken wings, salads, hoagies, burgers, soups, pasta, and specialty sandwiches. Short Stop also have a deli section in the market where they sell fresh cheeses, meats, and vegetables.

They also offer gluten-free pizzas, delivery options, and a selection of beer and wine to accompany your meal. Business hours are Sun. to Thurs. 10AM – 9PM and Weekends 10AM – 10PM.

Address: 101 S Fountain Ave, Springfield, OH 45502
Phone: (937) 342 3615
Services: Dine-in / Curbside pickup 

Crust & Company is a restaurant in Springfield Ohio, owned and operated by Dan and Lisa Freeman. It offers freshly baked breads and authentic Roman-style pizza, cooked on a wooden paddle using authentic Italian ingredients.

Crust and Company Pizza Springfield Ohio

The restaurant opened in 2018 and serves lunch and dinner, with a focus on “pizza alla pala” or “pizza on the paddle”, a rectangle shaped crust with a crispy bottom and a soft airy interior. In addition to pizza, the restaurant also offers freshly baked bread in the morning, with a goal to bake several hundred loaves a day, ranging from traditional baguettes, sourdough and other specialty breads.

Big Chain Pizza in Springfield

Springfield, Ohio is home to several popular chain pizza restaurants, including Domino’s Pizza, Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, Little Caesars and Donato’s. The addresses for these restaurants in Charleston are:

  • Domino’s Pizza: 417 W McCreight Ave, Springfield, OH 45504
  • Papa John’s: 1668 E Main St, Springfield, OH 45503
  • Pizza Hut: 2955 Derr Rd, Springfield, OH 45503
  • Little Caesars: 2142 E Main St, Springfield, OH 45503
  • Donato’s Pizza:732 S Burnett Rd, Springfield, OH 45503

Each of these chain pizza restaurants offers a variety of menu items, including classic pizzas, sides, and desserts, as well as delivery and carryout options.

Summing Up

The pizza restaurants in Springfield Ohio offers a wide range of pizzas and dining styles to suit all tastes and preferences. From the timeless charm of Catanzaro’s Pizza to the innovative menu at Rapid Fired Pizza, the restaurants featured in this list are sure to provide a memorable dining experience. So next time you’re craving a slice (or a whole pie), be sure to check out one of these top pizza spots in Springfield, Ohio.